Knife in the Back

Divided Argument

We catch up on the nomination of Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson, a new opinion by Justice Breyer, revisit a debate about who the greatest law professor on the Supreme Court is, and talk through each of our recent scholarly efforts. Tune in to hear Dan surprisingly attack Will's Fourth Amendment views from the right flank, learn an interesting tidbit about Justice Brandeis, and get some insight into the mysterious originalist gathering in San Diego. 

2022-03-02 58 min Transcript

Available Results

Generated results are saved to the knowledge database for reuse and search.

No generated results are available for this episode yet.

Extract Knowledge

Pick what you want extracted first. Model, scope, and chapter options appear after a template is selected.

Generated results for public episodes are saved to the knowledge database so they can be reused and searched later.

Transcript

Will: Let's just [unintelligible . And then, Justice Alito, I think, part of what marks him is just he is very committed to not being a chump. It's just another theory of precedent, in a way. He's very committed to the view that if this doctrine doesn't apply for the goose, then it also doesn't apply for the gander, and vice versa. That's popped up in a lot of famously strange concurrences.
Will: [chuckles] Not [unintelligible on that score. One of the consequences along the way is, I talk about the California v. Texas, the Affordable Care Act case that we talked about, and Justice Gorsuch was wrong to think that the Affordable Care Act was inseparable, although Justice Thomas and Justice Gorsuch--[crosstalk]
Dan: Okay, interesting. I don't know how Justice [unintelligible is under that task, because I'm not sure she has introduced huge new ideas that have been game changing, but maybe. Okay, you're not going to back away from that. Can we just talk about one other piece of Supreme Court trivia about the Justices? One second. Which I didn't know, maybe you knew. Remember Justice Brandeis who we've talked about, because we didn't remember, he is from Kentucky, even though Brandeis University is in Massachusetts. He cowrote this before he was a Judge, cowrote this famous article with Samuel Warren, who is his law partner about the right to privacy, this emerging common law right to privacy. That was very influential, highly cited. And I was actually looking at that article, we're using it in the Fourth Amendment article and saying that there's some intellectual connection between this and what the court has done.

Chapters

No chapters available.