Credibility Crisis in Science with Thomas Plümper and Eric Neumayer
In this episode, Thomas Plümper and Eric Neumayer explore the hidden challenges in modern science, from outright fraud to the subtler practice of “tweaking” data that distorts results. They examine why the self-correcting nature of science often falls short, how incentives and academic pressure drive misconduct, and the double-edged role of AI in both enabling and detecting fraud. The conversation also tackles debates around p-values and statistical reasoning, shares cautionary case studies, and proposes solutions like greater data transparency and stronger verification standards.
Chapters
00:00 Introduction to Fraud in Research
06:21 The Nature of Fraud Detection
08:56 Incentives and Motivations for Fraud
10:43 Self-Correction in Science
12:13 Understanding Statistical Significance
13:04 The Role of Replication in Research
14:32 Bayesian vs Frequentist Approaches
23:09 Understanding Bayesian Statistics and Its Implications
26:24 The Humility of Empirical Science
27:16 Concrete Examples of Scientific Fraud
32:52 Proposed Solutions to Scientific Fraud
34:50 The Reality of Scientific Fraud and Human Nature
Guest Links
You can purchase their book here (https://amzn.to/3Ole3lY)
Follow Eric Neumayer on LinkedIn - (https://linkedin.com/in/ericneumayer)
Follow Breaking Math on
Substack (https://breakingmath.substack.com/)
Twitter (https://x.com/breakingmathpod)
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/breakingmathmedia/)
Bluesky (https://bsky.app/profile/breakingmath.bsky.social)
Website (https://www.breakingmath.io/)
YouTube (https://www.youtube.com/@BreakingMathPod)
Follow Noah on
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/profnoahgian/)
Twitter (https://x.com/ProfNoahGian)
Bluesky (https://bsky.app/profile/profnoahgian.bsky.social)
Follow Autumn on
Twitter (https://x.com/1autumn_leaf)
Bluesky (https://bsky.app/profile/1autumnleaf.bsky.social)
Instagram (https://www.instagram.com/1autumnleaf/)
Substack (https://substack.com/@1autumnleaf)
Available Results
Generated results are saved to the knowledge database for reuse and search.
Extract Knowledge
Pick what you want extracted first. Model, scope, and chapter options appear after a template is selected.
Transcript
Podcast Transcripts | RSS.com You are using an old version of Internet Explorer, which is not supported any more by Microsoft. To fully take advantage of our service, we recommend to user a modern browser, such as Google Chrome . Sign up free Features Podcast Hosting Launch Your Podcast into the Stratosphere Podcast Analytics Navigate Your Podcast Analytics with Ease Distribution Distribute Your Podcast Across the Galaxy Monetization Turn Your Podcast into a Cosmic Cash Flow AI Transcription Boost the Visibility and Accessibility Collaborators Unite your podcast with multi-user access Podcast Website Establish Your Podcast's Home Base Podcasting 2.0 Propel Your Podcast into the Next Frontier Embeddable Player Beam Your Podcast Across the Digital Galaxy Privacy Protect your privacy Social Media Sharing Amplify Your Podcast Audio to Video Convert audio episodes into videos Podcast Support Trusted by Podcasters Worldwide PAID Programmatic Ads for Podcasts All features Features Podcast Hosting Launch Your Podcast into the Stratosphere Podcast Analytics Navigate Your Podcast Analytics with Ease Distribution Distribute Your Podcast Across the Galaxy Monetization Turn Your Podcast into a Cosmic Cash Flow AI Transcription Boost the Visibility and Accessibility Collaborators Unite your podcast with multi-user access Podcast Website Establish Your Podcast's Home Base Podcasting 2.0 Propel Your Podcast into the Next Frontier Embeddable Player Beam Your Podcast Across the Digital Galaxy Privacy Protect your privacy Social Media Sharing Amplify Your Podcast Audio to Video Convert audio episodes into videos Podcast Support Trusted by Podcasters Worldwide PAID Programmatic Ads for Podcasts All features Resources LEARN RSS.com Knowledge Base How to Start a Podcast Best Podcast Mics Best Podcast Headphones How to Start a Podcast on Spotify How to Start a Podcast on Apple Podcasts How to Create an RSS Feed How to Record an Episode Understanding Podcast Analytics MORE FROM RSS.COM Partners Reviews Tools PodViz - Audio to Video Find my feed Switch to RSS.com Resources LEARN RSS.com Knowledge Base How to Start a Podcast Best Podcast Mics Best Podcast Headphones How to Start a Podcast on Spotify How to Start a Podcast on Apple Podcasts How to Create an RSS Feed How to Record an Episode Understanding Podcast Analytics MORE FROM RSS.COM Partners Reviews Tools PodViz - Audio to Video Find my feed Switch to RSS.com Pricing Podcasts True Crime News Comedy Society & Culture Business Health & Fitness Education Technology Personal Journal Sports Spirituality & Religion All Podcasts Podcasts True Crime News Comedy Society & Culture Business Health & Fitness Education Technology Personal Journal Sports Spirituality & Religion All Podcasts Sign up free Sign In Sign In Sign up for free Episode Transcripts Boost the Visibility, SEO and Accessibility of Your Podcast Harness the power of AI to create accurate transcripts and expand your podcast's reach - at no extra cost. While many of our competitors charge for AI transcripts, we provide them for free with all our paid plans, so you can focus on growing your audience without worrying about hidden fees. Try RSS.com for free 14 Languages Supported! Break through language barriers and reach a global audience. SEO Boost Make your content discoverable across the galaxy. Accessibility Make your content more accessible so everyone can enjoy your episodes. Expand Your Reach Multi-Language Support : Our AI-powered transcript generator automatically detects the language of your podcast episode and translates it into one of 14 supported languages , making your content accessible to a global audience. Enhance Discoverability : Make it easier for new listeners to find your content by creating SEO-friendly searchable text versions of your episodes. Increase Accessibility and Engagement : Make your podcast more accessible by providing transcripts, ensuring that all listeners can enjoy your content. Don't Pay Extra : All our paid plans come with AI-generated and human editable transcripts. Podcast Transcripts Simplified RSS.com's AI transcription feature is your universal transcribe in the vast podcast universe. With the push of a button, our advanced AI technology converts your episode audio into accurate readable text that will appear in Apple Podcasts and other popular apps. How to use RSS.com's Transcripts Why Podcasters Choose RSS.com Move your podcast to RSS.com and get 6 months free! Transfer your podcast to RSS.com and publish all your episodes to YouTube, plus you’ll get automatic transcriptions and 6 months free as our way of saying welcome to the RSS.com family. Moving your podcast is fast, easy, free and your followers won’t notice a thing. Get 6 months free More features Collaborators Unite your team and simplify how you manage your show with RSS.com's collaboration tools. Learn more Podcast Website Create a stunning, fully-optimized website for your podcast with RSS.com's built-in tools. Learn more Podcasting 2.0 Embrace the future of podcasting with RSS.com's cutting-edge Podcasting 2.0 features. Learn more © RSS America LLC. Resources What’s New ✨ Affiliates Blog Press Press Kit Media Kit Support More from RSS.com Partners Reviews Tools Audio to Video Find my feed Switch to RSS.com Legal Cookie policy Privacy policy Terms of Service Community Check out all the great shows hosted on RSS.com . See podcasts Choose language English Español Italiano